What do you guys think of this auto. It is the first one I have ever seen like this. Most of the signature stickers I have seen have bj's name above his nickname centered on the sticker. Even the letters seem almost too neat to be bj's

I was wondering the same thing.  The auto does look a little different than most Penn red inks that I have seen.  I messaged the seller and he told me that he has two of them. 

I am no expert but it seems legit to me.
But it is really hard to tell from just a picture.

Hmmmm?  I went back to the old cardboard box with my Round 1 collection and looked at mine.  It's looks legit, but it would help if he had a better quality picture.  It was a redemption but the quality is the same as with all Round 1 autos.  There is chipping on the edges.  The only Round 1 redemption auto with the better quality control was the Rich Franklin autograph which was a replacement for Roger Huerta.  Here is a scan of my BJ Penn Red Ink from 2009.

just odd, looks like somebody trying their best to copy a real one