umm hands down the rd one. Not only is the rd one more than likely their rookie or rookie auto but round ones are just all around more valuable/desirable and more likely to hold value. But also depends on the fighter though of course. I would take the non rd one of a "hotter" (more wins/potential wins,title contention,=more future value) or one that you are just a bigger fan of than just any random rd 1. But if it's the same fighter then of course the rd 1 all day.

I think that the red ones probably sell for more. The gear autos are in WAY better condition though. Some people are paranoid about fake rd 1 red autos and might prefer the gear ones because they would be very hard to fake.

tough call because some of the red ink auto's have the fighter's nickname in the sig and haven't signed like that with any other auto.  IE: rampage, BJ, Anderson.

rd 1, i like the gear autos, but rd2 i like the reds better than the gears.. weird.